7 Best Gray Eyebrow Pencils 2024

by  Mila M.Cosmetologist

( As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases at no cost to you. )

Are you struggling to find the perfect eyebrow pencil for your gray hair? You’re not alone! Many people find matching their brow color with graying hair challenging. In this article, we’ve carefully selected and reviewed some of the best gray eyebrow pencils available in the market in 2024.

Dive in as we navigate through top picks, different types, and how to choose an eyebrow pencil that will complement your silver locks perfectly. Get ready to embrace a touch of grace by accentuating those gorgeous grays!

  • Gray eyebrow pencils are essential for gray hair as they provide a natural look that complements the hair color.
  • There are different types of gray eyebrow pencils available, including wooden pencils, microblading pens, and natural beauty options.
  • When choosing a gray eyebrow pencil, consider your hair color and skin tone, determine your preferred application method, and look for long-lasting and waterproof options.

Best Gray Eyebrow Pencils 2024

Here are some top picks for gray eyebrow pencils that will help you achieve natural-looking brows to complement your gray hair:

Kosas Brow Pop

The Kosas Brow Pop is a top pick for gray hair eyebrow makeup. It’s hassle-free to use since it doesn’t require any additional application tools. Plus, it comes with a built-in spoolie that makes blending easy and seamless.

With its natural and clean ingredients, this eyebrow pencil is perfect for those who prefer a more minimalist approach to beauty products. The Kosas Brow Pop will help you achieve beautifully groomed brows that perfectly complement your gray hair.

Sappho New Paradigm’s Brow Pomade

Sappho New Paradigm’s Brow Pomade is another excellent choice for a gray eyebrow pencil. This pomade offers long-lasting color and can help achieve a more defined look for your brows.

With its creamy texture, it glides on smoothly and allows for precise application. The brow pomade comes in different shades of gray, allowing you to find the perfect match for your hair color.

It is also made with clean beauty ingredients, so you can feel good about using it on your skin. Enhance your natural gray eyebrows with Sappho New Paradigm’s Brow Pomade for a polished and put-together look.

Kimiko Beauty Super Fine Eyebrow Pencil

The Kimiko Beauty Super Fine Eyebrow Pencil is a fantastic option for achieving precise and natural-looking brows. Its ultra-fine tip allows for easy application, giving you control over the shape and definition of your eyebrows.

Whether you have gray hair or are looking to enhance your natural brow color, this pencil offers a range of shades that will suit various skin tones and hair colors. The long-lasting formula ensures that your brows stay in place all day without smudging or fading.

With its blendable and buildable texture, you can create both subtle and bold looks effortlessly.

Eye Embrace Warm Betty & Cool Helen Eyebrow Pencils

Eye Embrace Warm Betty and Cool Helen Eyebrow Pencils are excellent options for those with gray hair. These eyebrow pencils offer a range of colors to suit different skin tones and enhance your natural eyebrows.

The Warm Betty shade is perfect for warmer undertones, while the Cool Helen shade works well for cooler undertones. Both pencils are long-lasting and easy to apply, allowing you to achieve defined and fuller-looking brows effortlessly.

By choosing Eye Embrace Warm Betty or Cool Helen Eyebrow Pencils, you can confidently embrace your gray hair while enhancing your overall look.

Ownest 6-in-1 Eyebrow Pencil

The Ownest 6-in-1 Eyebrow Pencil is a versatile and convenient option for those with gray hair. This eyebrow pencil offers six different shades, allowing you to find the perfect match for your eyebrows.

The long-lasting formula ensures that your brows stay in place all day, while the built-in spoolie brush helps to blend the color seamlessly. Whether you prefer a soft and natural look or a more defined brow, the Ownest 6-in-1 Eyebrow Pencil has got you covered.

Overtone Hair Color for Gray Hair

Overtone Hair Color is a great option for individuals with gray hair who want to add some color and vibrancy. This product allows you to experiment with different shades, from subtle pastels to bold neons.

It’s easy to use and doesn’t require any bleaching or damaging processes. Plus, Overtone is known for its long-lasting formula that keeps your hair looking vibrant and beautiful. Give your gray hair a pop of color with Overtone Hair Color!

Why Gray Eyebrow Pencils are Essential for Gray Hair

Gray eyebrow pencils serve as a crucial tool in your makeup kit, especially when you have gray hair. The advantage of using these colored pencils is their ability to provide a natural look better than black or brown alternatives.

Think about it, using darker shades like black and brown can create an artificial look that contrasts drastically with your hair color.

The trick to enhancing beauty lies in maintaining harmony between the eyebrows’ shade and your mane. Therefore, investing in the best gray eyebrow pencil allows for this perfect blend, resulting in a polished yet subtle appearance.

Another notable benefit of cool gray pencils is their versatility across different hair colors making them ideal even for those with salt-and-pepper or silver hair.

Moreover, many beauty experts recommend ensuring that your brow shade complements both -your graying hair and skin tone simultaneously. This means not going too dark on the brows which could dominate lightened locks but selecting soft blonde, light ash or taupe hues instead that lift and warm the complexion while retaining understated definition.

Types of Gray Eyebrow Pencils

There are several types of gray eyebrow pencils to choose from, including wooden pencils, waterproof options, microblading pen styles, and natural beauty alternatives.

Wooden eyebrow pencils

Wooden eyebrow pencils are a classic and popular choice for filling in and shaping eyebrows. They offer precise control and ease of application, making them ideal for achieving natural-looking brows.

With a finely sharpened tip, you can create hair-like strokes that mimic the appearance of real brow hairs. Wooden eyebrow pencils are also versatile as they come in various shades to match different hair colors, including gray.

Whether you have light gray or dark gray hair, there is a wooden eyebrow pencil shade that will enhance your brows and give them definition without looking too harsh or overdone.

Microblading eyebrow pens

Microblading eyebrow pens are a popular choice for achieving natural-looking brows. They provide precise application and can create hair-like strokes that mimic real eyebrows. These pens often come with a fine tip, allowing for more control and precision during the application process.

The microblading effect can give your brows a fuller and more defined appearance, making them stand out even more against gray hair.

Natural and clean beauty options

When it comes to choosing a gray eyebrow pencil, there are natural and clean beauty options available. These products are made with high-quality ingredients that are better for your skin and the environment.

Look for eyebrow pencils that are free from harsh chemicals, parabens, and synthetic fragrances. Opt for brands that use natural pigments derived from plants or minerals. Some popular choices include organic brow pencils made with botanical oils and waxes, as well as cruelty-free formulas that have not been tested on animals.

Embrace the power of nature while enhancing your brows with these clean beauty options.

How to Choose the Right Gray Eyebrow Pencil

To choose the right gray eyebrow pencil, consider your hair color and skin tone, determine your preferred application method, and look for long-lasting and waterproof options.

Consider your hair color and skin tone

When choosing the right gray eyebrow pencil, it’s important to consider your hair color and skin tone. For individuals with gray hair, shades like soft blonde, light ash, and taupe are great starting points as they complement the natural gray tones.

These lighter shades can be built upon for a more defined look if desired. Additionally, considering your skin tone is key to finding a shade that enhances both your brows and overall complexion.

Makeup artist Gucci Westman suggests picking a brow pencil shade that not only complements your gray hair but also boosts your skin tone at the same time. So take into account both factors when selecting the perfect gray eyebrow pencil for you.

In determining which shade of gray eyebrow pencil to choose, keep in mind that cool gray is a versatile option that can work well with various hair colors. This means it’s not limited to just those with gray or silver hair; even individuals with other hair colors can benefit from using cool gray shades for their brows.

Determine your preferred application method

To find the perfect gray eyebrow pencil for you, it’s important to determine your preferred application method. Some people prefer the traditional wooden eyebrow pencils because they provide more control and precision.

If you’re looking for a long-lasting option, you might consider a waterproof eyebrow pencil that can withstand sweat and humidity. For those who want a more natural look, microblading eyebrow pens are a great choice as they create hair-like strokes.

Lastly, if you’re into clean beauty options, there are natural gray eyebrow pencils available as well. Consider your personal preference and desired outcome when choosing the right application method for your gray eyebrows.

Look for long-lasting and waterproof options

When choosing a gray eyebrow pencil, it’s important to look for options that are long-lasting and waterproof. These features ensure that your eyebrows stay in place throughout the day, even if you come into contact with water or sweat.

Long-lasting pencils will keep your brows looking flawless without the need for frequent touch-ups. Waterproof formulas are especially useful if you lead an active lifestyle or live in a humid climate.

By opting for a long-lasting and waterproof gray eyebrow pencil, you can achieve perfectly groomed brows that withstand any conditions.


When it comes to finding the best gray eyebrow pencil, there are plenty of options to choose from. Whether you have silver hair or just a touch of gray, a gray eyebrow pencil can help enhance and define your brows.

Consider factors such as hair color and skin tone when selecting the perfect shade. Don’t forget to look for long-lasting and waterproof options for all-day wear. With the right gray eyebrow pencil, you can achieve natural-looking brows that beautifully complement your hair color.


1. What is the best gray eyebrow pencil for different shades of gray hair?

The best gray eyebrow pencil can vary based on your hair color and undertones, with options from light to dark, including charcoal and taupe tones.

2. Can an eyebrow pencil match natural gray or silver hair?

Sure! Eyebrow pencils are available specifically for natural grey, salt & pepper and silver hairstyles.

3. Can Taupe Eyebrow Pencil be Used as an Alternative to Gray Eyebrow Pencil?

Yes, taupe eyebrow pencils can be used as an alternative to gray eyebrow pencil. Taupe is a versatile shade that can work for a range of hair colors, including gray. It offers a soft and natural look, making it a great choice for those seeking a subtle brow enhancement.

4. Is there a long-lasting option for a gray eyebrow pencil?

Yes, certain brands offer longlasting options in their range of the best grey eyebrow pencils.

5. Are there affordable drugstore options for gray eyebrow pencils?

Absolutely! There are many affordable drugstore choices when it comes to selecting the best gray eyebrow pencil that fits your budget without compromising quality.

6. Are Eyebrow Pencils for Grey Hair and Gray Eyebrow Pencils the Same?

Yes, grey hair eyebrow pencils and gray eyebrow pencils are the same. Despite the different spellings, they both refer to pencils specifically designed for filling in and defining eyebrows that have turned grey. This type of eyebrow pencil helps to create a natural look and blend seamlessly with grey hair.

7. Can I find a suitable shade if I have warm or cool undertones?

Definitely! Brands produce both warm and cool-toned versions of their products such as dark brown or blackbrown so you can choose the perfect fit.

Best Eyebrow Pencil for Redheads
Best Eyebrow Pencil for Grey Hair
Best Taupe Eyebrow Pencil of 2024
Best Eyebrow Pencil for No Eyebrows
Best Organic Eyebrow Pencil
Best Korean Eyebrow Pencil of 2024
Brow Pencil vs Brow Gel
Eyebrow Pencil vs Powder
Eyebrow Gel vs Pencil
Best Eyebrow Pencils 101: Top Versatile Brow Pencils Of 2024
7 Best Gray Eyebrow Pencils 2024
No comments to show.
Mila, the veteran beauty cosmetics professional and author of this article, while cutting and styling the hair of her client

Hi! I’m Mila M. I share my 44 year-experience as a Cosmetologist & Beauty Professional in this blog. This content is for educational purposes only and does not constitute professional advice. Consult your trusted Beauty Professional for your personal beauty needs.

Get your FREE copy.

Sign Up & Subscribe

* indicates required

Intuit Mailchimp