Eyebrow Gel vs Pencil vs Powder vs Pomade: 4 Brow Products

by  Mila M.Cosmetologist

( As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases at no cost to you. )

Struggling to choose whether to go for an eyebrow gel or pencil? Eyebrow makeup is a valuable tool in anyone’s beauty arsenal, but choosing the right product can be tricky. This article will guide you through the pros and cons of both brow products, helping you make an informed decision based on your unique needs.

Let’s dive into this amazing world of brow grooming!

  • Eyebrow gel is ideal for those with coarse hair or gaps in their eyebrows, providing fullness and hold throughout the day.
  • Eyebrow pencil allows for precision detailing and shaping, making it perfect for adding detail to sparse areas.
  • The choice between eyebrow gel and pencil depends on your personal preference and desired result. Experimenting with both can help you find the perfect product to enhance your eyebrows.

4 Types of Brow Products

Eyebrow Pencil and Brow Powder are two common brow products that you can choose from to achieve your desired look.

Eyebrow Pencil

Eyebrow pencils boast a versatility that makes them essential in any beauty routine. You can use them to enhance the natural structure of your brows, fill in any gaps, or correct asymmetry.

The soft texture allows for easy smudging and blending if you prefer a softer look. They are also great for adding detailed lines to create an illusion of individual hairs where there might be sparse tails or even bald spots.

If you want sharper edges or more defined eyebrows, using a pencil gives you control over precision strokes needed for microblading effects.

Brow Powder

Brow powder is an excellent choice for those who prefer a more natural look and dislike the waxy texture of pencils. It offers a softer and more subtle finish, making it ideal for those who want to achieve a soft, feathered effect.

Brow powder is great for filling in sparse areas or adding depth and definition to the eyebrows. It can also be used to create a more symmetrical appearance if you have uneven brows or sparse tails.

With brow powder, you have full control over the intensity of color, allowing you to build it up gradually for a customized look that suits your preferences.

Tinted Gel

Tinted gel is a great option for those with coarse eyebrow hair or gaps that need filling in. The gel works to add fullness and definition to your brows, giving them a more polished look.

It’s perfect for taming unruly hairs and creating a sleek shape that lasts all day long. Whether you want natural-looking brows or bold and dramatic ones, tinted gel can help you achieve the desired effect.

With its easy application using a spoolie wand, tinted gel is an essential tool in your brow grooming routine.


Pomade is a versatile brow product that offers definition and structure to your eyebrows. It has a creamy texture that allows for easy application and blending. Pomades are ideal for those with coarse hair or gaps in their eyebrows, as they offer long-lasting hold and fill in sparse areas effectively.

With a small amount of pomade applied using an angled brow brush, you can shape and sculpt your brows with precision. This product is also great for adding dimension and creating an eyebrow tail that appears natural.

Whether you prefer bold or subtle brows, pomade can help you achieve the desired look effortlessly.

4 Benefits of Using Each Brow Product

Discover the unique advantages of using different brow products, from pencils for precision to gels for fullness. Find out which product suits your needs best!

Pencils for precision

Eyebrow pencils are a great tool for achieving precise and defined brows. They allow you to fill in sparse areas with accuracy, shape your brows to perfection, and create natural-looking strokes.

With an eyebrow pencil, you have full control over the intensity of color and can easily achieve a more symmetrical appearance by adding subtle strokes where needed. The waxy texture of the pencil makes it easy to smudge and blend for a softer look.

Additionally, brow pencils can add volume to your brows without creating harsh lines, giving you fuller-looking eyebrows with precision and ease.

Powder for a natural finish

Brow powder is the go-to option if you’re looking for a natural finish to your eyebrows. Unlike pencils, powders don’t have that waxy feel and provide a softer, more subtle look. They are perfect for those who want their brows to appear fuller without any harsh lines or precision shaping.

Powders also help eliminate the texture that some people dislike about pencils. So, if you prefer a more natural and effortless-looking brow, reach for a brow powder to achieve that desired finish.

Gel for fullness

Eyebrow gel is a great option if you want to achieve fullness in your brows. It works like hairspray, helping to hold and control thick eyebrow hair throughout the day. With its creamy texture, the gel coats each individual hair strand, making them appear fuller and more defined.

Whether you have naturally sparse brows or gaps that need filling in, using an eyebrow gel can give your eyebrows the appearance of volume and thickness. So if you’re looking for that perfectly groomed and full look, give eyebrow gel a try!

Pomade for definition

Pomade is a great option if you want well-defined and structured eyebrows. It has a creamy texture that allows for easy application and precise shaping. Whether you have coarse hair, gaps, or asymmetry in your brows, pomade can help fill them in and create a more symmetrical look.

With its long-lasting formula, your defined brows will stay put all day. Pomade can be applied with a brow brush for added control and precision. Achieve the perfect arches with pomade for beautifully shaped and defined eyebrows that make a statement.

3 Factors to Consider When Choosing a Brow Product

Consider your brow texture and thickness, desired look, and experience level when choosing between an eyebrow gel or pencil.

Brow texture and thickness

The texture and thickness of your eyebrows play a crucial role in determining which brow product is best for you. If you have coarse hair or gaps in your brows, an eyebrow gel would be the ideal choice.

The gel’s formula provides hold and control, helping to fill in those sparse areas and create a more defined shape. On the other hand, if your brows are on the finer side or lack structure, an eyebrow pencil is perfect for adding detail and shaping them precisely.

With its ability to create fine lines and blend easily, a pencil can give you natural-looking brows with just the right amount of definition. Ultimately, it all comes down to personal preference and what kind of result you want to achieve.

Desired look

When it comes to choosing between eyebrow gel and pencil, your desired look plays a crucial role. If you have coarse hair or gaps in your brows, an eyebrow gel can help fill them in and provide fullness.

It works like hairspray for your eyebrows, offering hold and control throughout the day. On the other hand, if you’re looking for precision detailing and shaping, an eyebrow pencil is ideal.

You can easily define sparse areas with precision and create a more defined shape. Both options are effective tools for achieving well-groomed brows according to personal preferences and desired results.

Experience level

Choosing the right brow product depends on your experience level. If you’re new to doing your eyebrows or prefer a more beginner-friendly option, an eyebrow pencil might be a great choice.

Pencils are easy to use and allow for precise detailing and shaping of the brows. On the other hand, if you have more experience or want to achieve a fuller look with minimal effort, eyebrow gel can be your go-to product.

It helps fill in gaps and adds volume to coarse hair, giving you well-defined brows that stay in place all day long. Ultimately, whether you choose an eyebrow gel or pencil comes down to personal preference and desired results.

Eyebrow Gel vs Pencil

Discover the best brow product for your needs – whether you need precision or fullness, eyebrow gel or pencil has you covered. Keep reading to find out more!

Gel for coarse hair or gaps

Eyebrow gel is the perfect solution for those with coarse hair or gaps in their eyebrows. It works like hairspray, providing hold and control to tame unruly brows. The gel formula adds fullness and volume, filling in any sparse areas for a more defined look.

Whether you have thick eyebrow hair that needs taming or gaps that need to be filled, eyebrow gel is an effective tool to achieve well-groomed brows throughout the day. It’s a great choice for those who want long-lasting hold and natural-looking brows without harsh lines or a waxy texture.


In conclusion, both eyebrow gel and pencil are valuable tools for achieving beautifully groomed brows. Eyebrow gel is perfect for those with coarse hair or gaps, providing fullness and hold throughout the day.

On the other hand, an eyebrow pencil is great for adding detail and shaping with precision. Ultimately, the choice between gel and pencil comes down to personal preference and desired result.

Experimenting with both can help you find the perfect product to enhance your eyebrows.


1. What are the key differences between eyebrow gel and pencil?

Eyebrow gel has a creamier consistency, while pencils have a waxy nature which is excellent for brow shaping and filling in eyebrows.

2. How does eyebrow powder compare to gels or pencils?

Brow powders usually come in a palette with multiple shades that can be mixed for precise color matching, making them different from both eyebrow gels and pencils.

3. What types of products are available for brow maintenance?

Besides eyebrow gel, pencil, and powder; you may use products like brow wax or tint for holding hairs in place along with an eyebrow brush for application; additionally tools such as an eyebrow stencil could help streamline brow shaping process.

4. Can I maintain my microbladed eyebrows using these products?

Yes! Regardless if your brows are naturally dense or microbladed, all the said items including the likes of Brow pomade can enhance their appearance by adding volume.

5. Which product should I pick among Eyebrow filler, Eyebrow Pomade and Eyebrow Wax?

Your choice depends on what you want: fillers create fuller brows; pomades give bold looks whereas waxes tame unruly hairs—so it’s best to choose based on individual needs.

Best Eyebrow Pencil for Redheads
Best Eyebrow Pencil for Grey Hair
Best Gray Eyebrow Pencil
Best Taupe Eyebrow Pencil of 2024
Best Eyebrow Pencil for No Eyebrows
Best Organic Eyebrow Pencil
Best Korean Eyebrow Pencil of 2024
Brow Pencil vs Brow Gel
Eyebrow Pencil vs Powder
Best Eyebrow Pencils 101: Top Versatile Brow Pencils Of 2024
Eyebrow Gel vs Pencil vs Powder vs Pomade: 4 Brow Products
No comments to show.
Mila, the veteran beauty cosmetics professional and author of this article, while cutting and styling the hair of her client

Hi! I’m Mila M. I share my 44 year-experience as a Cosmetologist & Beauty Professional in this blog. This content is for educational purposes only and does not constitute professional advice. Consult your trusted Beauty Professional for your personal beauty needs.

Get your FREE copy.

Sign Up & Subscribe

* indicates required

Intuit Mailchimp