Mascara vs False Eyelashes

Mila, the veteran beauty cosmetics professional and author of this article, while cutting and styling the hair of her client

Hi! I’m Mila. I share my 44-year experience as a Beauty Professional in this blog.This content is for educational purposes only and does not constitute professional advice. Consult your Aesthetician for your beauty needs.

Are you torn between mascara and false eyelashes for that perfect lash look? Weighing the pros and cons can be quite tricky. This article offers a comprehensive comparison, untangling your doubts about cost-effectiveness, convenience, health considerations, and overall impact.

Let’s dive into finding out which one matches perfectly with your beauty needs!

Key Takeaways

  • Mascara enhances natural lashes, adding length and volume with just a few swipes.
  • False eyelashes offer a dramatic and customizable look, but require skill to apply properly.
  • Mascara is more affordable than false eyelashes, making it a budget – friendly choice.
  • Applying mascara is quick and easy, while false lashes can be time – consuming to apply.

Pros and Cons of Mascara

Mascara enhances your natural lashes, is less expensive than false eyelashes, but can be messy to apply.

Enhances natural lashes

Mascara offers an easy way to enhance your natural lashes. With just a few swipes, it can add length and volume. Mascara works by coating your eyelashes, making them appear thicker and longer than they actually are.

Certain types of mascara also improve lash health over time by providing essential nutrients for growth. However, heavy use can cause the lashes to become brittle if not properly cared for.

Though less prominent compared to false eyelashes, mascara maintains the natural beauty of your lashes while giving them an attractive boost.

Less expensive

Mascara is a more budget-friendly option compared to false eyelashes. With mascara, you can achieve longer and fuller lashes without breaking the bank. It’s an affordable choice that won’t burn a hole in your pocket.

Plus, there are plenty of drugstore mascaras available that deliver great results at a fraction of the cost of high-end brands. So, if you’re looking for an economical way to enhance your lashes and get that natural effect, mascara is definitely the way to go.

False eyelashes, on the other hand, can be quite costly. They usually come with a higher price tag compared to mascara. Additionally, false eyelashes require adhesive glue or professional application services which further add to the expense.

While they offer dramatic and customizable looks, it’s important to consider their impact on your wallet before investing in them as they might not be as cost-effective as using mascara in the long run.

Can be messy

Mascara application can be messy, especially if you’re not experienced or have shaky hands. It’s easy to accidentally smudge or get mascara on your eyelids and lower lash line. Additionally, waterproof mascaras can be difficult to remove, leading to smudging and clumping if not properly cleaned off.

Pros and Cons of False Eyelashes

False eyelashes offer a dramatic and customizable look, but they can be costly and require skill to apply properly.

Dramatic and customizable look

False eyelashes offer a dramatic and customizable look that can instantly transform your eyes. Whether you want long, voluminous lashes or a more natural effect, false eyelashes come in various styles to suit your preferences.

You can choose from different lengths, thicknesses, and shapes to achieve the desired level of drama. With false lashes, you have the flexibility to experiment and create different looks for special occasions or everyday wear.

So if you’re looking to make a statement with your lashes, false eyelashes are an excellent option that allows you to customize your look according to your style and mood without committing to permanent solutions like eyelash extensions.


While false eyelashes can give you a dramatic and customizable look, they do come with a higher price tag compared to mascara. Eyelash extensions, in particular, can be quite costly as they typically last three to four weeks before requiring maintenance or retouching.

On the other hand, mascara is a more affordable option with lower initial costs. While you may need to repurchase it over time, it is still more cost-effective than investing in regular eyelash extensions.

Keep in mind that while false eyelashes may seem expensive upfront, they can actually be better for the health of your natural lashes compared to mascara, which can weaken and make them brittle over time.

Requires skill to apply

Applying false eyelashes is a task that requires skill and practice to master. Unlike mascara, which can be easily swiped on with a wand, false lashes need careful placement and precision to achieve the desired look.

It’s important to have steady hands and patience when applying false eyelashes, as one wrong move can result in crooked or unnatural-looking lashes. Professional application is also an option for those who are not confident in their own skills.

Remember, practice makes perfect when it comes to mastering the art of false lash application.

Difference in Convenience between Mascara and False Eyelashes

Mascara is a quick and easy way to enhance your lashes, while false eyelashes require more time and skill to apply. Find out which option suits your lifestyle best!

Quick and easy application for mascara

Applying mascara is quick and easy, making it a convenient choice for anyone looking to enhance their lashes. With just a few swipes of the wand, you can achieve longer, fuller-looking lashes in no time.

There’s no need to spend hours carefully placing false eyelashes or visit a professional for application. Mascara allows you to effortlessly achieve that natural and fluttery look without any hassle.

So whether you’re getting ready for work or heading out for a night on the town, mascara is your go-to beauty tool for instantly transforming your lashes.

Time-consuming and need for professional application for false eyelashes

Applying false eyelashes can be a time-consuming process that requires some professional skill. It’s not as simple as swiping on mascara; it takes precision and practice to get them just right.

You have to carefully measure, trim, and glue each lash strip in place, making sure they look natural and stay put all day. Plus, if you’re new to false lashes, it might take a few tries before you get the hang of it.

So, if you’re looking for a quick and easy way to enhance your lashes without the hassle of false eyelashes, mascara might be your best bet.

Cost Comparison: Mascara versus False Eyelashes

Mascara may have a lower initial cost, but false eyelashes can be more cost-effective in the long run. Find out why by reading more!

Lower initial cost for mascara

Mascara is a more affordable option compared to false eyelashes. When you’re starting out, the initial cost of purchasing mascara is much lower than buying false eyelashes and adhesive.

With mascara, you can achieve longer and fuller lashes without breaking the bank. So if you’re looking for a budget-friendly way to enhance your natural lashes, mascara is the way to go!

Higher cost for false eyelashes, but more cost-effective in the long run

False eyelashes may have a higher upfront cost compared to mascara, but they can actually be more cost-effective in the long run. While mascara needs to be replaced every few months, false eyelashes can last for multiple uses if properly cared for.

This means that despite the initial investment, false eyelashes can save you money over time by eliminating the need for frequent mascara purchases. So, even though they may seem pricier at first glance, don’t forget to consider their long-term value and potential savings.

Health Considerations: Mascara versus False Eyelashes

False eyelashes can potentially damage your natural lashes and improper cleaning can lead to eye infections. Read more to find out the best option for your eyelash health.

Potential for damage to natural lashes with false eyelashes

False eyelashes, while they create a dramatic and customizable look, can potentially cause damage to your natural lashes. The adhesive used to apply false lashes can be harsh on the delicate hairs, leading to breakage and even loss of your own lashes over time.

Additionally, improper removal or cleaning of false eyelashes can increase the risk of eye infections. It’s important to take proper care when using false eyelashes to maintain the health of your natural lashes and minimize any potential damage.

Can lead to eye infections if not cleaned properly

Not properly cleaning your false eyelashes can lead to eye infections. It’s important to maintain good hygiene and remove any dirt, oils, or makeup residue from your false lashes after each use.

Failing to do so can create a breeding ground for bacteria, which may cause irritation and infection in the eyes. To ensure the health of your eyes and natural lashes, make sure you clean your false eyelashes thoroughly using a gentle cleanser or makeup remover specifically designed for removing adhesive residue from lashes.


In the debate between mascara and false eyelashes, both options have their advantages. Mascara is more convenient and offers a natural effect, while false eyelashes provide a dramatic and customizable look.

Consider your preferences, budget, and skill level to determine which option is best for you. Achieve long, fluttery lashes with either choice!


1. What is the difference between Mascara and False Eyelashes?

Mascara is an eye makeup product applied to natural lashes to add volume and length, while false eyelashes are beauty tools attached to enhance lash appearance for a more dramatic effect.

2. Can I use Mascara on Fake lashes?

Yes, you can apply mascara on fake lashes; using a volumizing or lengthening mascara can help blend your natural and false eyelashes together.

3. Are there any precautions while swimming with Mascara or False Eyelashes?

For mascara users, it’s best to opt for swim-proof variants when swimming. For fans of false eyelashes, consider semi-permanent ones as they tend to withstand water better.

4. How does one care for frail lashes in comparison between applying Mascara vs using False Eyelashes?

When dealing with frail lashes, consider using a gentle volumizing or lengthening mascara rather than attaching heavy false eyelashes which may cause strain over time.

5. What gives a bigger impact: Using an Eyelash Curler with Mascara or Applying False Lash Effect products?

While both visually affect eye makeup dramatically; an eyelash curler paired with mascara typically enhances your natural look whereas the application of false lash effect cosmetics creates standout long eyelash looks usually desired for special occasions.

Mascara vs False Eyelashes
No comments to show.

Get your FREE copy.

Sign Up & Subscribe

* indicates required

Intuit Mailchimp

error: Alert: Not allowed.