7 Pros and Cons of Permanent Eyeliner

by  Mila M.Cosmetologist

( As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases at no cost to you. )

Are you tired of applying eyeliner every day? You’re not alone; many people are turning to a permanent solution: the eyeliner tattoo. This blog post will guide you through what permanent eyeliner is, its pros and cons, and important factors to consider before getting one.

Keep reading to see if this beauty enhancement aligns with your lifestyle and needs!

  • Permanent eyeliner provides a long-lasting solution for your makeup needs, saving you time and effort in your daily beauty routine.
  • With proper aftercare, the color of permanent eyeliner can last for several years before eventually fading.
  • Permanent eyeliner offers versatility in styles, allowing you to achieve your desired look without the hassle of daily application.
  • However, there are some cons to consider such as the risk of pigment migration and discomfort during treatment and recovery.
  • Removing permanent eyeliner can be challenging and may require professional assistance.

What Is Permanent Eyeliner?

Permanent eyeliner is a cosmetic procedure that involves tattooing pigment onto the lash line to create the appearance of perfectly applied eyeliner that lasts for an extended period of time.

Difference between permanent and semi-permanent eyeliner tattoos

Permanent and semi-permanent eyeliner tattoos differ mainly in duration, application process, and color retention. Permanent eyeliner involves injecting pigments into the dermal layer of the skin to create a lasting effect.

It’s typically beneficial for those who seek an enduring solution for their makeup needs or have physical limitations hindering regular application. However, despite its name, this method isn’t completely permanent as it fades over time due to factors like individual skin type and lifestyle choices.

On the other hand, semi-permanent eyeliner involves pigmenting only the epidermal layer of skin, which results in a less durable outcome compared to permanent methods. This technique requires touch-ups more frequently but poses fewer risks such as reduced chances of pigment migration or allergic reactions caused by ink particles.

Thus deciding between these two types depends largely on your preferences regarding longevity versus versatility and your tolerance towards safety concerns or possible discomfort during treatment and recovery periods.

How the tattoo process works

The process of getting a permanent eyeliner tattoo involves the following steps:

  1. Consultation: You will have a discussion with a professional artist to determine your desired eyeliner style and thickness.
  2. Numbing: The technician will apply a numbing cream or gel to minimize any discomfort during the procedure.
  3. Preparation: Your eyes will be thoroughly cleaned and prepared for the tattooing process.
  4. Tattooing: Using a handheld device called a tattoo machine, the artist will implant pigment into the upper or lower lash line, creating your chosen eyeliner look.
  5. Pigment selection: The artist will select a pigment color that complements your skin tone and eye color.
  6. Healing process: After the tattooing is complete, you will need to follow proper aftercare instructions to ensure proper healing and minimize any potential complications.

Preparation and aftercare

To get the best results from your permanent eyeliner treatment and ensure a smooth recovery, it’s important to follow these preparation and aftercare steps:

  1. Consultation: Schedule a consultation with a reputable and experienced cosmetic tattoo artist to discuss your desired look and any concerns or questions you may have.
  2. Skin preparation: Keep your eyelid area clean and free from any makeup or lotions before the procedure. This will help ensure the ink adheres properly to your skin.
  3. Numbing cream: If you’re concerned about discomfort during the procedure, ask your artist if they offer a numbing cream that can be applied beforehand.
  4. Healing time: After the procedure, your eyelids may be swollen and slightly red. This is normal and should subside within a few days. Avoid touching or rubbing your eyes during the healing process.
  5. Avoid excess moisture: Stay away from activities that can cause excessive sweating, such as intense workouts or saunas, as this can affect the healing process.
  6. Sun protection: Protect your eyelids from direct sunlight while they are healing by wearing sunglasses or using sunblock with a high SPF.
  7. Follow the artist’s instructions: Your cosmetic tattoo artist will provide specific aftercare instructions for you to follow. This may include avoiding certain skincare products or treatments during the healing period.

4 Pros of Permanent Eyeliner

Permanent eyeliner offers a long-lasting solution for your makeup needs, saving you time and effort in your daily beauty routine.

Long-lasting solution

Permanent eyeliner provides a long-lasting solution for your makeup needs. Unlike traditional eyeliner that needs to be applied every day, permanent eyeliner is tattooed onto the skin, allowing you to wake up with perfectly defined eyes every morning.

This can save you time and effort in your daily beauty routine. With proper aftercare, the color of permanent eyeliner can last for several years before eventually fading. So if you’re looking for a hassle-free and durable option for beautiful eyeliner, permanent eyeliner may be the perfect choice for you.


Permanent eyeliner can be a time-saving solution for those who struggle with applying traditional eyeliner daily. With permanent eyeliner, you won’t have to spend precious minutes each morning trying to achieve the perfect wing or make sure both eyes match.

The tattooed liner will stay in place all day long, saving you valuable time and effort in your beauty routine. Plus, it’s especially beneficial for individuals with physical limitations who may find it difficult or impossible to apply makeup themselves.

So if you’re looking for a convenient and efficient way to enhance your eyes, permanent eyeliner could be the answer.

Versatility in styles

Permanent eyeliner offers versatility in styles, allowing you to achieve your desired look without the hassle of daily application. Whether you prefer a bold and dramatic winged liner or a subtle enhancement to your lash line, permanent eyeliner can be customized to suit your individual preferences.

With various techniques and pigment colors available, you have the flexibility to create different looks that complement your unique features and personal style.

Eventual fading

Over time, permanent eyeliner may fade. The retention of color can vary depending on your skin type and lifestyle choices. Thicker skin tends to fade faster than thinner skin. Factors such as sun exposure and certain beauty products can also contribute to the fading process.

It’s important to keep in mind that while permanent eyeliner offers a long-lasting solution, it is not completely immune to the effects of time.

4 Cons of Permanent Eyeliner

There are several cons to consider when it comes to permanent eyeliner, including the risk of pigment migration, discomfort during treatment and recovery, difficulty in removal, and a trend-dependent look.

Risk of pigment migration

Pigment migration is a potential risk associated with permanent eyeliner. This means that the pigments used in the tattooing process may move or spread over time, leading to an undesirable appearance.

The exact cause of pigment migration can vary and is influenced by factors such as skin type and lifestyle choices. It’s important to be aware of this risk before deciding to get permanent eyeliner, as it may not give you the desired long-lasting result you were hoping for.

Treatment and recovery discomfort

The treatment and recovery process of permanent eyeliner can be uncomfortable for some individuals. The procedure involves the use of needles to deposit pigment into the skin, which may cause mild discomfort or even pain during application.

Additionally, there is a period of healing and recovery after getting permanent eyeliner where redness, swelling, and tenderness around the treated area are common. It’s important to follow proper aftercare instructions provided by your technician to minimize any discomfort and promote optimal healing.

Difficulty in removal

Removing permanent eyeliner can be a challenging task. Unlike traditional makeup that can be easily wiped away, permanent eyeliner requires specialized techniques for removal. The ink used in the procedure is designed to be long-lasting, which means it may not fade or come off easily.

This can pose difficulties if you decide you no longer want the eyeliner or if you want to change the style. Seeking professional help from a trained technician is often necessary to safely and effectively remove permanent eyeliner without causing damage to your skin.

Trend dependence

Permanent eyeliner may not be adaptable to changing makeup trends. As beauty trends evolve over time, what is considered fashionable today might not be the case tomorrow. This means that if you opt for permanent eyeliner, you might find yourself stuck with a look that is no longer in style.

It’s essential to consider whether you’re willing to commit to a particular eyeliner style long-term or if you prefer the flexibility of changing your look with different makeup trends.

Considerations and Costs

When getting permanent eyeliner, it is important to consider potential allergic reactions, safety concerns, pain and discomfort during the treatment, and the expense involved. Read more to make an informed decision about this beauty enhancement.

Allergic reactions

The ink used for permanent eyeliner can sometimes cause allergic reactions in certain individuals. These reactions can manifest as redness, swelling, itching, or even a rash around the tattooed area.

It’s important to note that everyone’s skin is different and may react differently to the pigments used in permanent makeup. If you have a history of allergies or sensitive skin, it’s recommended to do a patch test before getting permanent eyeliner to check for any potential adverse reactions.

Safety concerns

Safety concerns should be taken into consideration when considering permanent eyeliner. One of the risks is the potential for allergic reactions to the ink used in the procedure. It’s important to do a patch test beforehand to ensure that you don’t have any adverse reactions.

Additionally, there is a risk of pigment migration, which can result in an uneven or less desirable appearance. While rare, it’s something to be aware of before getting permanent eyeliner done.

Finally, it’s worth noting that removing permanent eyeliner is not an easy task and may require additional treatments or procedures.

Pain and discomfort

Permanent eyeliner procedures can be uncomfortable and may cause pain and discomfort during and after the treatment. The process involves using a needle to deposit ink into the skin along the lash line, which can result in stinging or a sensation similar to scratching.

While numbing agents are often used to minimize discomfort, some individuals may still experience mild to moderate pain during the procedure. Additionally, the recovery period can also be uncomfortable as it involves redness, swelling, and scabbing around the treated area.

It’s important to consider these potential side effects before deciding on permanent eyeliner as a cosmetic option.


Permanent eyeliner is a beauty investment that comes with a price tag. The cost of permanent eyeliner can vary depending on factors such as location, the expertise of the technician, and the complexity of the design.

On average, it can range from $200 to $600 for the initial procedure. Additionally, touch-ups may be necessary every few years to maintain the desired color intensity and shape, which can add to the overall expense over time.

While permanent eyeliner offers long-lasting results, it’s important to consider this financial commitment before deciding if it’s right for you.


Permanent eyeliner offers a long-lasting solution for those who want to save time on their makeup routine and enjoy the versatility of different styles. However, it’s important to consider the potential risks such as pigment migration and difficulty in removal.

While permanent eyeliner can be a convenient option, make sure to weigh these pros and cons before making a decision.


1. What are the Pros and Cons of Permanent Eyeliner?

Permanent eyeliner, a form of cosmetic tattooing or micropigmentation, has benefits like saving time on makeup application but also drawbacks such as potential allergic reactions to permanent makeup.

2. Is permanent eyeliner painful?

Application of tattooed eyeliner can cause discomfort for some individuals due to the micropigmentation process.

3. Are there any risks associated with permanent makeup?

Yes, besides possible discomfort during application, other risks involved with permanent cosmetics include migration of pigments in the skin and difficulty in removal of permanent makeup if desired later.

4. How does semi-permanent eyeliner compare to a fully inked one?

Semi-permanent liner doesn’t penetrate the skin as deeply as conventional tattooed eyeliner which may let it fade over time but makes it easier to remove than full blown permanent eyelid tattoos.

5. Is there an alternative if I’m concerned about foreign particles from standard eyeliners?

An alternative is cosmetic tattooing which offers longer lasting definition compared to regular eyeliners but this procedure has its own pros and cons too.

7 Pros and Cons of Permanent Eyeliner
No comments to show.
Mila, the veteran beauty cosmetics professional and author of this article, while cutting and styling the hair of her client

Hi! I’m Mila M. I share my 44 year-experience as a Cosmetologist & Beauty Professional in this blog. This content is for educational purposes only and does not constitute professional advice. Consult your trusted Beauty Professional for your personal beauty needs.

Get your FREE copy.

Sign Up & Subscribe

* indicates required

Intuit Mailchimp