Best Eyeliners 101: Tested Top Eyeliner Reviews Guide

by  Mila M.Cosmetologist

( As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases at no cost to you. )

Embarking on the journey to find the impeccable eyeliner can feel like you’re chasing a horizon in the makeup & cosmetics universe —especially when you’re pining for that seamless line or the quintessential wing. Believe me, I understand the struggle all too well; it’s no small feat to uncover an eyeliner that stays put instead of melting away before your day is halfway through.

After diving deep into a sea of user reviews and personally trying out various brands (and yes, word has it that Stila Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner snagged the best overall pick this year), I’ve curated a list brimming with stellar standouts in each category—for your eyes only.

Whether you need an indestructible waterproof formula or something foolproof for eyeliners novices, this guide won’t disappoint. Let’s embark on this beauty adventure together! Keep reading—you’re about to make quite the discovery!

  • Stila Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner is a top choice with its precise felt tip and award-winning waterproof formula that stays on through tears, sweat, and accidental rubs.
  • Drugstore finds like Maybelline Eye Studio Master Precise Eyeliner impress with their budget-friendly prices and ergonomic grip for steady application of ultra-fine lines.
  • For those willing to splurge, the Victoria Beckham Satin Kajal Liner offers long-lasting wear in creamy shades while Tom Ford’s Eye Defining Pen boasts a dual-ended design for versatile looks.
  • Gel eyeliners are favored for precision; KVD Beauty Super Pomade Vegan Eyeliner stands out for its smudge-free coverage and range of finishes from matte to glossy.
  • Beginners can rely on user-friendly eyeliner options such as Shiseido gel pencils or Sephora Collection’s ultra-fine brush tips for easy control when learning how to apply liner.

Overall Best Eyeliners: Waterproof

I’ve scoured high and low to find the best waterproof eyeliners that deliver on their promise to withstand any challenge. Trust me, I know how frustrating it can be when your perfect cat eye starts running at the first sign of rain or emotion.

But with Stila Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner, you’re in for a game-changer. Its precise felt tip allows for smooth application, ensuring sharp lines that stay put from morning till night.

Chanel Stylo Yeux Waterproof Long-Lasting Eyeliner is another stellar pick if you’re after luxury that lasts. The creamy formula glides effortlessly across your lash line without tugging or skipping, setting quickly to a long-lasting finish which means no smudging—even during those summer days or sappy movie sessions.

You’ll understand why professional makeup artists hold these pencils in such high regard once you experience their resilient beauty firsthand.

Stila Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner

I’m always on the lookout for a liquid liner that won’t let me down, and let me tell you, Stila Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner is a game-changer. Its award-winning formula glides on effortlessly with a fine marker-like tip, making precise application a breeze.

Whether I’m aiming for subtle definition or going bold with a cat-eye look, this eyeliner gives me the control to nail it every time.

Crafted to stay put through tears, sweat, and even an accidental eye rub—it’s no wonder this is the #1 selling waterproof liquid liner. Drying quickly to avoid smudges or runs means my makeup looks sharp all day long.

And if you prefer super-fine lines, their micro tip version has got your back too! Ready to switch it up? Well then, Chanel Stylo Yeux Waterproof Long-Lasting Eyeliner could be perfect for adding some variety to your collection.

Chanel Stylo Yeux Waterproof Long-Lasting Eyeliner

If you’re on the hunt for an eyeliner that stays put through wind and rain, Chanel Stylo Yeux Waterproof Long-Lasting Eyeliner might just be your new best friend. Its creamy texture glides onto your lids without tugging or pulling, creating a smooth line with minimal effort.

You’ll find it available in various shades to match any mood or occasion, from classic black to vibrant colors perfect for a smoky eye.

This pencil liner boasts waterproof capabilities that deliver intense eye definition without the dreaded panda eyes at day’s end. Even if you have sensitive skin, this non-irritating formula is gentle enough for daily wear.

Just keep in mind that if you go bold with a thicker line, some color may transfer or crease as time ticks on. But don’t let that discourage you; with its hardwearing properties, this Chanel offering is still among the favorites in many makeup bags.

Moving from the luxurious feel of department store beauty treasures, let’s explore what best gel eyeliners offer when we aim for durability and precision.

Best Drugstore Eyeliners

An array of drugstore eyeliners displayed on a modern vanity.

Looking for the best drugstore eyeliners that won’t break the bank? I’ve tested and reviewed numerous options to find the top picks that deliver high-quality results at an affordable price.

From precise pencil liners to long-lasting liquid formulas, you can count on brands like NYX, Maybelline, L’Oréal, and wet n wild for smudge-free wear all day.

I’ve highlighted 17 of the best drugstore liquid eyeliners in 2023, with a focus on products like Covergirl Perfect Point Plus for its anti-smudge and long-wear capabilities. Plus, if you’re aiming for a sharp cat-eye look that lasts from morning meetings through evening events, my testing has uncovered some great long-wear liquid eyeliner options.

Maybelline Eye Studio Master Precise Eyeliner

I’ve tested and loved the Maybelline Eye Studio Master Precise Eyeliner because of its long-lasting, smudge-proof, and waterproof formula. This eyeliner features an ultra-fine tip that allows for precise application, making it perfect for creating thin to thick lines or classic cat eye looks.

With its no-slip ergonomic grip, this eyeliner pen is suitable for all eye makeup looks, providing ease of control while applying the product.

Maybelline’s Eye Studio Master Precise Eyeliner is included in the top 8 best liquid eyeliners due to its extra fine tip (0.4 mm) that offers exceptional precision from the first application.

NYX Mechanical Eyeliner Pencil

The NYX Mechanical Eyeliner Pencil comes in an impressive range of 33 shades, offering versatile options for different looks. Its creamy formula makes application smooth and effortless.

Whether you prefer a matte or metallic finish, this eyeliner has got you covered with its variety. While the retractable design adds convenience to use, some users have noted that it can be prone to smudging and smearing.

This pencil is highly pigmented, providing intense color coverage and making it a great option for those seeking bold and vibrant eye makeup.

Best Splurge Eyeliners

The best splurge eyeliners come from high-end brands like Stila, Tom Ford, and Fenty. These luxurious options are known for their rich pigmentation, smooth application, and long-wearing formulas.

They often feature precision applicators that make it easy to create a flawless wing or a precise line along the lash line. The Stila Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner is particularly notable as the top splurge eyeliner overall, offering intense color payoff and exceptional staying power.

Additionally, there are also more affordable splurge eyeliners available from brands such as Maybelline’s Master Precise Eyeliner, providing an accessible option for those looking to indulge in quality eye makeup products.

Victoria Beckham Satin Kajal Liner

The Victoria Beckham Satin Kajal Liner is a top choice for those seeking an effortlessly chic, long-lasting eyeliner. It glides on smoothly, delivering rich color and eye-comforting ease in just one stroke.

Available in flattering shades, this ultra-creamy liner ensures a dramatic look that stays put all day, thanks to its waterproof and long-wearing formula. With rave reviews from beauty enthusiasts, the Victoria Beckham Satin Kajal Liner is dangerously easy to use and can be found at various retailers.

Featuring an ultra-creamy texture and lasting performance, the Victoria Beckham Satin Kajal Liner is an excellent choice for creating stunning eye looks with minimal effort.

Tom Ford Eye Defining Pen Liquid Eyeliner Duo

I’ve tried many eyeliners, and the Tom Ford Eye Defining Pen Liquid Eyeliner Duo is undoubtedly a game-changer. This dual-ended liquid eyeliner boasts a calligraphy tip at one end and a brush at the other, making it incredibly versatile for achieving sleek to dramatic effects.

The formula is top-notch – it doesn’t bleed, smudge, or become flaky, yet it’s easy to remove when you’re ready. Plus, this liner is available in the blackest shade of black for ultimate precision.

Priced at $62 after tax and shipping might seem steep but considering its highly praised easy application, precision, long-lasting smudge-proof formula, and defining color makes every penny worth it.

Best Liquid Eyeliners

I’ve put together a comprehensive list of the top 8 best liquid eyeliners tested and reviewed this year, offering an array of options from matte to glossy finishes to suit diverse preferences.

This roundup features renowned brands like Rare Beauty by Selena Gomez and Lancôme Idôle, ensuring consumers have access to high-quality products that deliver on performance and longevity.

Moreover, readers can discover must-have long-wear liquid eyeliners for achieving that sharp cat-eye look that lasts throughout the day, including Stila Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner, Tarte Sex Kitten liner, and NYX matte liner – all favored choices among beauty enthusiasts.

KVD Beauty Tattoo Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner

I adore the KVD Beauty Tattoo Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner as it delivers bold, intense lines with its ultra-precise felt-tip brush. The jet-black formula creates impeccably sharp and long-lasting lines, perfect for achieving a variety of eyeliner looks.

This vegan and waterproof liquid eyeliner dries in seconds and stays put throughout the day, making it ideal for all-day wear. Whether you’re creating a classic winged eyeliner or experimenting with intricate designs inspired by tattoo artistry, rest assured that this eyeliner won’t budge or smudge.

Plus, removing it is hassle-free with makeup wipes.

Anastasia Beverly Hills Liquid Liner

Anastasia Beverly Hills Liquid Liner is a waterproof, highly-pigmented, true-black matte liquid eyeliner. Users and reviewers have recognized it as one of the best liquid eyeliners in 2023 due to its intense, vivid black pigment with only one stroke.

The fluid, water-based gel formula glides on evenly without dragging or skipping, setting quickly to a smudge-proof finish. Notably, this eyeliner is water-resistant and highly pigmented, ensuring long-lasting wear and intense color payoff.

The brand’s offering has received positive reviews and recommendations from users and beauty experts alike.

Best Pencil Eyeliners

Let’s take a closer look at the best pencil eyeliners for 2023. From long-lasting wear to smooth application, these top picks offer a range of benefits. The article also highlights the best waterproof pencil eyeliners, underlining their reliability and staying power in various conditions.

The comparison between drugstore and luxury brands provides insight into diverse options catering to different budgets and preferences. Additionally, there’s a list of recommended eyeliner pencils for everyday use and beginners, ensuring that there’s something suitable for everyone’s needs.

Charlotte Tilbury Rock ‘N’ Kohl Eyeliner Pencil

A waterproof kohl eyeliner pencil like Charlotte Tilbury Rock ‘N’ Kohl offers a versatile and long-lasting formula that combines the silky application of a liquid liner with the smudgy effect of a kohl.

Its Eye Cheat shade can brighten up your eyes for both special occasions and everyday use, making it a reliable option in any makeup collection. The no-nonsense, waterproof formula ensures that your eyeliner stays put without smudging throughout the day, providing easy application even for those with sensitive eyes or oily lids.

The hybrid nature of this product allows for flexibility in creating different looks, from precise lines to smoky effects. The ease of use makes it suitable for various skill levels and preferences, offering an opportunity to experiment with different styles effortlessly.

With its long-wear capability and rich pigmentation, Charlotte Tilbury’s Rock ‘N’ Kohl Eyeliner Pencil is undoubtedly a must-have addition to any beauty routine.

Hourglass Cosmetics 1.5MM Mechanical Gel Eye Liner

Now let’s talk about the Hourglass Cosmetics 1.5MM Mechanical Gel Eye Liner. This gel eyeliner boasts a highly pigmented and gel-like formula that ensures smooth, creamy application for a perfect line every time.

With 16 matte-to-metallic shades available, this long-wearing and smudge-proof liner is suitable for various skin tones and eye looks. Additionally, its saturated, matte color makes it ideal for creating precise lines with ease.

The Hourglass Cosmetics 1.5MM Mechanical Gel Eye Liner is considered one of the best clean gel eyeliners in the market, offering beauty enthusiasts an excellent option for achieving a flawless eye look without compromising on quality or performance.

Best Gel Eyeliners

Gel eyeliners are a top choice for achieving long-lasting and precise eye makeup looks. The best gel eyeliners come in various formats, including pencils, pots, and pens, delivering smudge-free coverage.

KVD Beauty Super Pomade Vegan Eyeliner is highly acclaimed as the top gel eyeliner of 2023 by makeup experts due to its remarkable staying power and precision application.

For those seeking enduring cat-eye perfection, there are options that offer long-wearing formulas capable of lasting through numerous hours without budging. Additionally, waterproof gel eyeliners provide a reliable solution for maintaining flawless eye makeup regardless of weather conditions or activities.

With choices available across different price points and features such as waterproof formulations for mature eyes, there’s a suitable gel eyeliner for everyone’s unique preferences and needs.

Melt Cosmetics Ultra Matte Gel Eyeliner

I love the Melt Cosmetics Ultra Matte Gel Eyeliner because it offers rich, ultra-pigmented color in shades like Onyx, Fortune, Slate, and Spliff. The smooth application makes it a breeze to create the perfect wing or line your lower lash line with precision.

This long-lasting gel liner provides intense pigmentation that stays put all day, making it an excellent choice for those with oily skin. Plus, its versatile formula allows you to use it as both an eyeliner and a cream shadow, giving you endless possibilities for creating stunning eye looks.

With an impressive average rating of 4.8-5.0 out of 5 stars from customer reviews on retailer sites, this gel eyeliner is highly regarded by beauty enthusiasts everywhere.

Bobbi Brown Long-Wear Gel Eyeliner

Transition: When it comes to gel eyeliners, the Bobbi Brown Long-Wear Gel Eyeliner stands out for its exceptional quality and long-lasting formula. It’s a top pick among beauty enthusiasts for its ease of application and stay-put formula.

With a variety of different shades available, this eyeliner offers versatile options to complement any look. The ultra-fine brush tip allows for precise and smooth application, creating the perfect line every time.

Plus, with its waterproof formula, you can count on this eyeliner to last all day without smudging or fading. A little bit goes a long way with this high-end makeup product that is definitely worth the investment for those seeking a reliable and beautiful eyeliner option.

What Makes Japanese Eyeliner Stand Out Among Other Brands?

When it comes to enhancing your eye makeup game, nothing quite stands up to the performance of a top-rated Japanese eyeliner. Known for its exceptional precision, long-lasting formula, and intense pigmentation, this eyeliner is a favorite among beauty enthusiasts. Its smooth application and smudge-proof finish set it apart from other brands.

Best Eyeliners for Everyday Use

Looking for the perfect eyeliner that will take you from day to night effortlessly? My top pick for everyday use is the Stila Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner, known for its long-lasting formula and precise application.

For those who prefer a more budget-friendly option, Maybelline Eye Studio Master Precise Eyeliner and Shiseido MicroLiner Ink Eyeliner are highly recommended. These eyeliners offer great pigmentation and staying power without breaking the bank.

When it comes to everyday use, I consider factors like ease of application and longevity. After extensive research and testing, these eyeliners have proven to be reliable choices that provide a smooth application and all-day wear.

Now, let’s explore some recommendations for beginners who are just starting their eyeliner journey.

Best Eyeliners for Beginners

For beginners, it’s essential to start with eyeliners that offer ease of application and precise control. Brands like Shiseido and Sephora Collection feature user-friendly options, such as gel pencils or ultra-fine brush tips, providing a perfect example for effortless application.

Melt Cosmetics also offers beginner-friendly choices with long-wear formulas, which is ideal for those who are just starting out in the world of eyeliner.

The best eyeliners for beginners should include features such as smudge-proof formulas and easy-to-use applicators. These products cater to newcomers by offering forgiving application techniques while still delivering quality results.

When navigating through various brands and types of eyeliner, look for products designed specifically for beginners to ensure a smooth transition into mastering the art of creating beautiful eye looks.

What Makes a Good Eyeliner?

A good eyeliner has a smooth, pigmented formula that glides effortlessly onto the skin. The best eyeliners are versatile, offering precision for creating both thin and thick lines.

The applicator should be easy to use, helping to achieve sharp, defined looks without smudging or fading throughout the day. When choosing an eyeliner, consider your desired look: liquid liners are great for bold lines while gel liners provide a more dramatic finish.

Additionally, identifying your eye shape will help in selecting the most flattering product.

Testing the formula and applicator is crucial before purchasing as it ensures compatibility with your style and preferences. Look for long-lasting formulas that won’t budge or transfer easily, giving you confidence in wearing your favorite looks all day.

What type of eyeliner is best for over 50?


When selecting the best eyeliner, consider the formula that suits your needs. Some formulas are waterproof for long-lasting wear, while others are more creamy and blendable for a softer look.

Look for formulas with high pigmentation to achieve intense color payoff in just one swipe. Additionally, opt for formulas that are smudge-proof and quick-drying to keep your eye makeup looking fresh all day.

Eyeliner formulas can range from traditional pencils to liquid or gel options. Each formula offers different benefits – pencil eyeliners provide versatility and ease of use, whereas liquid eyeliners offer precision and sharp lines.


The small felt tip applicator allows for precise application, making it easy to create thin, sharp lines for a subtle look or build up the eyeliner for a more dramatic effect. The fine point of the applicator provides control, enabling you to achieve your desired look with ease.

Whether you’re aiming for a delicate line along your lash line or a bold winged look, the small felt tip applicator offers versatility and precision without smudging or smearing.

Additionally, this type of applicator is ideal for those with shaky hands or beginners who are new to applying eyeliner. Its manageable size and maneuverability make it straightforward to use, resulting in flawless lines every time.

Consider your desired look

When choosing an eyeliner, it’s essential to consider the look you want to achieve. Whether you prefer a bold and dramatic eye or a more natural and subtle appearance, your desired look will influence the type of eyeliner that best suits your needs.

For a precise and defined line, liquid or gel eyeliners are great options, while pencil eyeliners are ideal for creating a softer and smudged effect. Consider whether you want to enhance your lash line or create a winged cat-eye look, as different types of eyeliners offer varying degrees of control and precision.

Understanding how each type of eyeliner can help you achieve your specific makeup goals is key in selecting the perfect product for your desired look. By taking into account factors such as ease of application, level of pigmentation, and staying power, you can confidently choose an eyeliner that aligns with your personal style preferences.

Identify your eye shape

Before purchasing your next eyeliner, let’s identify your eye shape to ensure the perfect application. There are 11 different eye shapes, each with a preferred liner style that enhances its natural contours.

Consider the importance of eyebrow shape in determining eye shape and utilize the 5 golden metrics for precise identification. Understanding your unique eye shape will guide you in selecting the ideal eyeliner that complements and accentuates your eyes effortlessly.

Differentiating among various eye shapes allows you to tailor your eyeliner application for optimal enhancement. Whether you have almond-shaped eyes, monolids, or hooded lids, knowing your eye shape empowers you to create looks that suit you best.

Test the formula and applicator before purchasing

Before making a purchase, it’s crucial to test the formula and applicator of the eyeliner. Doing so helps ensure that the product aligns with your specific needs and preferences. Consider factors such as dry time, ease of application, and whether it complements your eye shape.

To discover which eyeliner suits you best, take advantage of free testers at makeup stores or explore sample sizes to experiment at home. This proactive approach allows for a hands-on evaluation before committing to a full-size purchase.

It’s always worth investing time in finding an eyeliner that not only meets your expectations but also enhances your overall look.

Tips for Choosing the Right Eyeliner

When selecting the right eyeliner, consider the following factors:

  1. Determine the Formula: Decide if you prefer a liquid, pencil, or gel eyeliner based on your desired look and application confidence.
  2. Assess the Applicator: Choose an applicator that complements your skill level and desired outcome, whether it’s a flexible brush tip for precise lines or a soft pencil for effortless smudging.
  3. Consider Eye Shape: Identify your eye shape to select the most flattering eyeliner style, such as winged liner for almond-shaped eyes or tightlining for small or hooded eyes.
  4. Test Before Purchase: Try out different formulas and applicators to ensure they meet your expectations before committing to a purchase.
  5. Opt for Waterproof: If longevity is essential, opt for waterproof formulas that resist smudging and fading throughout the day.
  6. Look for Comfort: Consider any specific requirements such as sensitivity or contact lens wear when choosing an eyeliner designed for comfort and safety.

Which brand is best for eyeliner?

After considering different types of eyeliners and their specific uses, it’s essential to focus on the best brands available. Many factors go into determining the best brand for eyeliner, including formula quality, longevity, ease of application, and range of colors.

Stila Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner has consistently been praised for its precise application and long-lasting formula. Maybelline Eye Studio Master Precise Eyeliner is also highly regarded for its affordability without compromising on quality.

Additionally, Tom Ford and Fenty have gained popularity as top contenders in the realm of quality eyeliners with innovative formulas that cater to various makeup needs.

From waterproof liquid liners to easy-to-use pencil liners, several brands offer high-quality products suitable for every consumer’s preferences and needs.

When should I buy new eyeliner?

Before buying new eyeliner, consider the lifespan of your current product. Over time, eyeliners can dry out or lose their pigmentation, affecting their performance and potential for causing eye irritation.

To ensure optimal results, replace liquid and gel liners every three to six months, pencil eyeliners every one to two years, and powder eyeliners annually. Additionally, if you notice changes in the texture or smell of your eyeliner that indicate spoilage or if you’ve recently experienced an eye infection, it’s best to invest in a new eyeliner promptly to maintain eye health and makeup application quality.

Should I get pencil, liquid, or gel?

For a soft and subtle look, pencil eyeliner is the best option. It’s perfect for creating natural-looking lines and is great for beginners. On the other hand, liquid eyeliner provides bold definition with its precise application.

This type of liner is ideal for achieving dramatic and sharp looks that last all day. Gel eyeliner offers a versatile option as it can be applied with an angled brush to create various styles, from smudged to defined lines.

When deciding between these options, consider your desired style and level of expertise in applying eyeliner. Each type has its unique advantages, so it’s important to choose based on your preferred look and comfort level with application techniques.

Moving on to “Which color eyeliner is best?”

Which color eyeliner is best?

Different eye colors can be enhanced by choosing the right eyeliner shade. For example, brown-eyed individuals may find that deep plum or metallic bronze eyeliners make their eyes stand out, while blue eyes tend to pop with navy or cobalt blue liners.

Green-eyed beauties can consider using rich burgundy or purple liners to accentuate their eye color, and those with hazel eyes might want to try emerald green or golden brown eyeliner shades for a striking effect.

It’s not just about your eye color; sometimes playing around with contrasting shades can also create an alluring look. For instance, if you have light-colored eyes like blue or green, a dark black liner can provide a stunning contrast and draw attention to your eyes.

On the other hand, dark-colored eyes such as brown might benefit from lighter shades like soft golds or warm coppers for an impactful appearance.

Which eyeliner is best for natural look?

When aiming for a natural look, consider using a soft and creamy pencil eyeliner in brown or taupe shades. Look for formulas that glide on easily without tugging at the delicate skin around your eyes.

Opt for smudgeable pencils that allow you to create a subtle, blended line, enhancing your eyes with a more relaxed and effortless appearance.

For those who prefer liquid eyeliners, choose one with a fine tip applicator that enables you to create thin, precise lines. This will help achieve a more defined yet still natural-looking effect.

Additionally, seek out long-wearing and waterproof formulas to ensure the liner stays put throughout the day without smudging or fading.

What type of eyeliner is best for over 50?

For mature women, gel cream texture eyeliners are recommended as they ensure a long-lasting and mess-proof application. Long-wear liquid eyeliners are also highly recommended to guarantee that the eyeliner lasts for hours without smudging.

The best options for aging eyes include silky gel formulas, water-resistant liquid liners, and smudge-proof creamy pencils. These options provide a reliable and flawless look without exacerbating any signs of aging around the eyes.

Which is the Best Eyeliner for Sensitive Eyes?

Having sensitive eyes doesn’t mean you have to compromise on the perfect eyeliner. Physicians Formula Eye Booster Lash 2-in-1 Boosting Eyeliner & Serum is a top pick for us due to its gentle formula that’s great for sensitive eyes.

It provides long-lasting wear without irritation, and it’s also infused with nourishing ingredients like chamomile and cornflower extract. Honest Beauty Liquid Eyeliner is another recommended option, especially for those with sensitive skin.

The gentle, water-based formula glides on smoothly and dries quickly, ensuring minimal irritation. Almay Eyeliner Pencil is great for people with sensitive eyes as it’s hypoallergenic and dermatologist-tested.

This careful selection of eyeliners ensures that individuals with sensitive eyes can still achieve their desired look without discomfort or irritation. When choosing an eyeliner for sensitive eyes, keep in mind factors such as gentleness of the formula and ease of application.

Next up: What is the best eyeliner that stays on all day?

What is the best eyeliner that stays on all day?

The Stila Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner is my top choice for the best eyeliner that stays on all day. Its richly pigmented formula delivers a smooth application, while the fine tip applicator allows for precise lines and wings.

The long-lasting wear ensures your eye makeup remains intact throughout the day, making it ideal for busy schedules or special events.

Revlon Colorstay Skinny Liquid Liner with its extra-narrow felt-tip brush also stands out as an excellent option. This feature makes it easy to achieve a flawless and long-lasting look without smudging or fading, providing an effortless solution for those seeking durable wear from their eyeliner.

How do I keep my eyeliner from coming off?

To keep your eyeliner from coming off, shake the eyeliner well before application to ensure a smooth and even flow. Applying eyeshadow beforehand can help absorb excess oil and prevent smudging throughout the day.

Additionally, investing in a high-quality, waterproof eyeliner can significantly reduce migration and smudging, ensuring long-lasting wear without constant touch-ups.

It’s important to also consider expert tips for applying eyeliner in specific areas prone to smudging, such as hooded eyes or the waterline. Keeping these strategies in mind will help you maintain a flawless eye look all day long.

What is the best and easiest eyeliner to use?

Shiseido MicroLiner Ink Eyeliner tops the list as the best eyeliner for beginners, thanks to its precise application and smooth consistency. Sephora Collection Colorful Wink-It Felt Tip Liquid Eyeliner also stands out as an easy-to-use option with its user-friendly felt tip design.

For those preferring gel eyeliners, Melt Cosmetics Ultra Matte Eyeliner is highly recommended for its creamy texture and effortless application. When it comes to drugstore options, Maybelline Hyper Easy Liquid Liner’s fine-tip applicator makes it one of the best choices for hassle-free use.

Deciding whether you prefer pencil, liquid, gel, or powder eyeliner can significantly impact ease of use and application. Each type offers unique advantages in terms of convenience when applying makeup – from the soft lines achievable with pencil liners to the precision offered by liquid formulations.

Understanding your preferences can help determine which type of eyeliner is easiest for you to use on a regular basis.

Ready to explore which brand is best suited for your specific needs?

Is it bad to wear eyeliner on the waterline?

Wearing eyeliner on the waterline can potentially cause issues due to the presence of specialized glands in that area. Not all eyeliners are suitable for the waterline, and using the wrong type can lead to problems.

Liquid liners, in particular, are not recommended for use on the waterline as they can become re-activated with natural moisture and tears. It’s essential to choose products specifically designed for waterline use and exercise caution when applying eyeliner in this sensitive area.

Some companies claim that their eyeliners are safer for waterline use because they do not include harmful ingredients found in other liners. When considering wearing eyeliner on the waterline, it is important to opt for waterproof formulas if one has hooded eyes to prevent smudging.

However, taking some precautions before applying any kind of liner near or on the waterline is always advisable.

How do you wear blue eyeliner?

When it comes to wearing blue eyeliner, the key is to keep it simple and let the color shine. Start by applying a light eyeshadow as a base, then gently line your upper lash line with the blue eyeliner.

You can also smudge a bit of the same liner on the outer half of your lower lash line for a subtle pop of color. To enhance your eyes further, add some mascara to make them stand out.

Additionally, if you want to take your look up a notch, consider creating a winged eyeliner effect using the blue pencil or liquid liner on your upper lash line. This classic technique can instantly elevate any makeup style and bring attention to your eyes in an elegant way.

What goes well with blue eyeliner?

Blue eyeliner pairs beautifully with neutral eyeshadow shades like browns, taupes, and creams for a subtle and everyday look. If you want to add a touch of glamour, consider combining blue eyeliner with metallic eyeshadows in gold, silver, or bronze tones.

For a more dramatic and colorful appearance, complementing the blue eyeliner with eyeshadow shades such as purples and greens can create an eye-catching style. These combinations provide versatility, allowing you to tailor your makeup to suit different occasions and moods.

Incorporating these eyeshadow pairings can elevate your overall look while accentuating the striking beauty of blue eyeliner. When selecting complementary colors for your eyeshadow palette, keep these simple yet effective suggestions in mind to enhance the impact of your makeup effortlessly.

What eyeliner is best for contact lens wearers?

If you wear contact lenses, finding the right eyeliner is essential for comfort and eye health. Look for hypoallergenic options that are gentle on sensitive eyes and won’t cause irritation when wearing contacts.

Opt for water-based or gel formulas that are less likely to flake or irritate your eyes while maintaining a defined look. Consider eyeliners labeled as ophthalmologist-tested or approved for contact lens wearers, ensuring they meet specific safety standards.

Always ensure that the eyeliner you choose is suitable for your individual needs to keep your eyes comfortable and healthy throughout the day.

Choose an eyeliner specifically designed for contact lens wearers to maintain eye comfort and health.

Which eyeliner do celebrities use?

Celebrities opt for Chanel Stylo Yeux Waterproof Long-Lasting Eyeliner and Charlotte Tilbury Rock ‘N Kohl Eyeliner in their daily routines. These choices provide the desired long-lasting wear, intense color payoff, and easy application that meet the demands of celebrity lifestyles.

When selecting an eyeliner, it is crucial to consider factors such as lasting power, ease of use, and overall aesthetic appeal. By choosing eyeliners favored by celebrities like these, you can achieve a glamorous look with confidence.

Now let’s explore which eyeliners are ideal for everyday use.


In conclusion, the top 11 best eyeliners of 2023 have been meticulously tested and reviewed to ensure precision and quality. These expert insights provide practical guidance for selecting the ideal eyeliner that meets your specific needs and preferences.

By integrating these strategies, readers can achieve flawless eye looks with ease, confidence, and long-lasting wear. The carefully curated list showcases the impact of choosing the right eyeliner, offering valuable resources to empower beauty enthusiasts in making informed decisions.

Embrace your unique style and enhance your makeup routine with the perfect eyeliner for effortlessly captivating eyes.


1. What should I look for in the best black eyeliner?

When choosing the best black eyeliner, look for one that applies smoothly, has great staying power like a waterproof mascara, and can create a straight line easily.

2. Do celebrity makeup artists have a favorite eyeliner?

Yes, many celebrity makeup artists favor eyeliners from brands like Urban Decay because they last a long time and give that perfect look.

3. Can you recommend an easy-to-use liquid eyeliner?

The NYX Epic Ink Liner is often recommended as one of the easiest liquid eyeliners to use thanks to its precise sponge tip.

4. Are there beauty products that help eyeliner stay on dry skin?

Using an eye primer before applying your favorite mascara or gel eyeliner pencil can help it stay put on dry skin.

5. How do I remove my waterproof mascara and gel eyeliner pencil properly?

To remove waterproof beauty products like mascara and gel liners, gently use a makeup remover suited for waterproof formulas with warm water.

6. What are some top-rated eyeliners mentioned in good housekeeping reviews?

Good Housekeeping mentions several top-rated eyeliners including the Urban Decay Perma Precision Liquid Eyeliner among their list of 11 best eyeliners for its quality at a great price.

No comments to show.
Mila, the veteran beauty cosmetics professional and author of this article, while cutting and styling the hair of her client

Hi! I’m Mila M. I share my 44 year-experience as a Cosmetologist & Beauty Professional in this blog. This content is for educational purposes only and does not constitute professional advice. Consult your trusted Beauty Professional for your personal beauty needs.

Get your FREE copy.

Sign Up & Subscribe

* indicates required

Intuit Mailchimp