Can You Use Brow Pencil as Eyeliner?

by  Mila M.Cosmetologist

( As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases at no cost to you. )

Are you wondering whether your brow pencil can multi-task as an eyeliner too? Brow pencils, traditionally used to fill and define eyebrows, have subtly different makeup than eyeliners.

This article is here to not only explore the feasibility but also guide you on using a brow pencil as eyeliner in ways that fit your style. Stay tuned for some surprising beauty hacks and tips!

  • Yes, you can use a brow pencil as an eyeliner by following the right techniques and considering the risks involved.
  • Brow pencils offer easy application, versatility, various color options, long-lasting wear, cost-effectiveness, and precision control when used as eyeliner.
  • However, using a brow pencil as eyeliner may result in uneven coloring, stiff lines, waxier texture, less saturation compared to eyeliners. They also have limited color options compared to traditional eyeliners.
  • Remember to choose the right type of eyebrow pencil based on your desired look – powder for soft brows or gel for defined brows.

Can You Use Brow Pencil as Eyeliner?

Yes, you can use a brow pencil as eyeliner if you follow the right techniques and consider the risks involved.

How to use eyebrow pencil as eyeliner

You’re curious about trying eyebrow pencil as an eyeliner, and it’s easier than you may believe. Here are the simple steps to get you started:

  1. First, ensure your eyebrow pencil is sharp for precise application.
  2. Next, sanitize the pencil tip with a quick wipe of rubbing alcohol to prevent any potential eye infections.
  3. Gently pull the skin next to your eyelid backward. This tightens the surface for a more comfortable drawing and helps create a smoother line.
  4. Begin by drawing lightly on your upper lash line, gradually building the color up until it reaches your desired intensity.
  5. Note that eyebrow pencils can be less saturated than eyeliners, so be patient with this process.
  6. If you want a smudged effect, use a smudge brush or Q-tip to gently blur the lines before they set.
  7. For those seeking a defined cat-eye or winged look, draw an upward angle at the corner of your eye and connect it back to your main line.
  8. Lastly, always remove all makeup thoroughly at night using proper cleansing products.

Risks and considerations

Using a brow pencil as an eyeliner may come with some risks and considerations to keep in mind. One risk is that eyebrow pencils are generally less saturated than eyeliners, so you may need to apply multiple layers for a more intense color.

Another consideration is that eyebrow pencils tend to be waxier, which can result in uneven coloring and stiff lines when used as eyeliner. Additionally, while it is generally safe to use eyebrow pencils on the waterline or as lip liner, they may not be as effective for contouring compared to specific contouring products.

Keep these factors in mind when using a brow pencil as eyeliner for the best results.

Pros of using brow pencil as eyeliner

Using a brow pencil as an eyeliner has several advantages:

  1. Easy Application: Brow pencils that are sharp provide precise and effortless application, allowing you to create defined lines with ease.
  2. Versatility: Brow pencils can be used for multiple purposes, including filling in your eyebrows and defining your eyes as eyeliner. This makes them a versatile addition to your makeup collection.
  3. Color Options: There is a wide range of color options available in brow pencils, allowing you to find the perfect shade to complement your eye color and skin tone.
  4. Long-Lasting: Many brow pencils are designed to be long-lasting, ensuring that your eyeliner stays put throughout the day without smudging or fading.
  5. Budget-Friendly: Using a brow pencil as an eyeliner can be more cost-effective than purchasing separate eyeliners, especially if you already have a brow pencil on hand.
  6. Precision Control: Brow pencils typically offer excellent precision control, which makes it easier to achieve different eyeliner styles – from thin lines to bold wings.

Cons of using brow pencil as eyeliner

Using a brow pencil as eyeliner has some drawbacks to consider.

  1. Uneven coloring: Brow pencils are typically designed for the eyebrows, so they may not provide an even color when used as eyeliner.
  2. Stiff lines: The application of a brow pencil may result in harsh and stiff lines along the lash line.
  3. Waxier texture: Eyebrow pencils tend to be waxier than eyeliners, which can make them more difficult to apply smoothly as eyeliner.
  4. Less saturation: Compared to eyeliners, eyebrow pencils usually have less pigmentation, which may result in a less intense and defined look.
  5. Limited options: Eyebrow pencils come in limited shades and may not offer the range of colors available with traditional eyeliners.

Different Types of Eyebrow Pencils

There are various types of eyebrow pencils to choose from, including powder, cream, gel, and antique pencils. Each type offers unique benefits and application techniques. Discover more about these eyebrow pencil types by clicking here!

Powder eyebrow pencils

Powder eyebrow pencils are a popular choice for filling in and shaping eyebrows. They come in a variety of shades to match different hair colors, making it easy to create natural-looking brows.

These pencils have a powdery texture that glides smoothly on the skin, giving you control over the intensity of color. With powder eyebrow pencils, you can achieve soft and defined brows that last throughout the day.

Cream eyebrow pencils

Cream eyebrow pencils are another type of eyebrow pencil that you can use as eyeliner. These pencils have a creamy texture, making them smooth to draw on your eyelids. They offer precision and control for creating defined lines.

However, keep in mind that cream eyebrow pencils may not be as pigmented or long-lasting as specific eyeliners. So, while they can work in a pinch, it’s always good to have an actual eyeliner pencil on hand for those days when you want a more dramatic look or need something that will stay put all day.

Gel eyebrow pencils

Gel eyebrow pencils are a popular choice for those who want precise and defined eyebrows. These pencils have a creamy consistency that glides smoothly on the skin, making them easy to apply.

The gel formula also helps in creating natural-looking brows with a long-lasting hold. Gel eyebrow pencils are highly pigmented, ensuring that you achieve intense color payoff with minimal effort.

They are perfect for filling in sparse areas, shaping your brows, and giving them an enhanced appearance. With their versatility and ease of use, gel eyebrow pencils are great for achieving beautiful eyebrows effortlessly.

Antique eyebrow pencils

Antique eyebrow pencils have a unique charm that sets them apart from modern options. These vintage pencils are often made of wood and can give you a nostalgic feel while adding character to your makeup routine.

While they may not have the same precision and pigmentation as contemporary products, antique eyebrow pencils can still be effective in filling in sparse brows or creating soft, natural-looking strokes.

The texture of these pencils is slightly different, but with practice, you can achieve beautiful results that complement your overall look. So if you’re looking for something special and love all things vintage, an antique eyebrow pencil might be the perfect addition to your beauty collection.

Eyebrow Pencils vs Eyeliner Pencils

Eyebrow pencils and eyeliner pencils have some key differences in their formulations and purposes.

Differences between eyebrow and eyeliner pencils

Eyebrow and eyeliner pencils, while similar in appearance, have key differences in their formulation and intended use. The distinctions largely lie in their waxiness, saturation levels and consistency.

FeatureEyebrow PencilsEyeliner Pencils
WaxinessEyebrow pencils are generally waxier than eyeliners. The purpose of this is to help the color adhere to the brow hair, making it easier to fill and shape the eyebrows.Eyeliner pencils are less waxy and smoother to allow for easy application around the delicate eye area. The smooth texture is ideal for creating precise lines and designs on the eyelid.
SaturationEyebrow pencils are less saturated. This allows for a more natural look when filling in the eyebrows, as heavy pigment can make the eyebrows appear unnatural.Eyeliner pencils have a higher saturation level for a bold, dramatic look. The strong pigmentation helps the eyeliner stand out on the eyelid and waterline.
ConsistencyMost eyebrow pencils can result in uneven coloring and stiff lines, depending on the brand and how you use them. However, they are excellent for filling in sparse areas of the eyebrow.Eyeliner pencils generally have a smoother and more consistent pigment release, creating a more defined and even line. This is essential for achieving various eye makeup looks, from a simple line to a dramatic cat-eye.

Remember, while it’s possible to use eyebrow pencils as eyeliner, the result may not be as saturated or as smooth as using a product specifically designed for eyelining.

Can eyeliner pencils be used as lipliners?

Eyeliner pencils can indeed be used as lipliners. They have a similar texture and can provide precise application to outline the lips or fill them in for long-lasting color. Just make sure to choose an eyeliner pencil that is safe for use around the mouth area, and always sharpen it before applying for better control and precision.

You can experiment with different shades of eyeliner pencils to create various lip looks, but keep in mind that they may not have the same range of colors as dedicated lipliners.

Tips for Using Brow Pencil as Eyeliner

To achieve the best results, apply the brow pencil eyeliner with short, light strokes for a natural look.

How to achieve desired results

To achieve the desired results when using a brow pencil as eyeliner, follow these steps:

  1. Ensure that your brow pencil is sharp for precise application.
  2. Gently pull the skin next to your eyelid back to create a smoother surface for drawing the line.
  3. Start by applying the pencil close to the lash line, gradually building up the intensity if needed.
  4. Use short, light strokes to mimic the look of natural eyelashes.
  5. If you prefer a smudged effect, use a small brush or sponge applicator to blend out the line.
  6. To create a more defined winged liner, extend the line slightly beyond the outer corner of your eye.
  7. Clean up any mistakes or uneven lines with a cotton swab dipped in makeup remover.
  8. Set the pencil eyeliner with translucent powder or an eyeshadow in a similar shade for longer – lasting wear.

Techniques for a natural look

  • Use short, light strokes with the eyebrow pencil to mimic the appearance of individual eyelashes.
  • Start at the inner corner of your eye and gradually darken the line as you move towards the outer corner.
  • Blend and soften the line by gently smudging it with a small brush or cotton swab.
  • Avoid drawing a harsh, thick line; instead, aim for a subtle enhancement of your lash line.
  • Opt for neutral shades that closely match your natural eyelash color for a more seamless look.
  • Consider using powder eyeshadow or matte brown shades from your eyebrow palette as an alternative for a softer, more natural effect.

Removing brow pencil eyeliner

Removing brow pencil eyeliner is a simple process that you can easily do at home. Here are the steps to effectively remove brow pencil eyeliner:

  1. Start by wetting a cotton pad or makeup remover wipe with your preferred makeup remover.
  2. Gently press the damp cotton pad onto your closed eye, focusing on the area where you applied the brow pencil eyeliner.
  3. Hold the cotton pad against your eye for a few seconds to allow the makeup remover to dissolve and break down the product.
  4. Gently swipe the cotton pad across your eye, moving in an outward motion to remove the brow pencil eyeliner.
  5. Repeat this process as needed until all traces of the liner have been removed.
  6. After removing the brow pencil eyeliner, rinse your face with water or use a gentle cleanser to wash away any remaining residue.

Can Eyeliner Products Be Used in Place of Magnetic Eyeliner for Magnetic Eyelashes?

Yes, eyeliner products can sometimes be used in place of magnetic eyeliner for magnetic eyelashes. However, they may not always provide the same level of hold and staying power as the dedicated magnetic eyeliner technique. It’s best to use a specific magnetic eyeliner for the most effective results.


Yes, you can definitely use a brow pencil as eyeliner. Just make sure your pencil is sharp for precise application and gently pull your eyelid back to draw a smooth line. While there may be some differences in texture and saturation between brow pencils and eyeliners, they are interchangeable for certain purposes like lining the waterline or even contouring.

So go ahead and experiment with your makeup tools!


1. Can you use a brow pencil as an eyeliner?

Absolutely! Eyebrow pencils and pencil eyeliners often have multiple uses and are in many aspects interchangeable, meaning you can apply eyebrow pencils as eye liners.

2. How does one apply eyebrow pencil as liner?

To use your eyebrow pencil as liner, just make sure it’s sharp enough to draw smooth lines and then simply apply it the same way you would with traditional kohl or pen eyeliner.

3. Are all types of eyeliners and brow pencils interchangeable?

While pencil variations like waterproof, long-lasting or colored eyeliner may be closest to standard brow pencils in terms of application ease, gel liners, liquid liners, kohl liners or cream-based products might not offer the same interchangeability experience.

4. Are there any drawbacks using a brow pencil instead of an eyeliner pen?

This largely depends on your personal preference for cosmetics. If you prefer smudge-proof properties that come with certain specific eye cosmetics like gel or liquid options, a standard brow pen might fall short.

5. Which is better for my eyes – A regular eye cosmetic product like an eyeliner pen or multi-use tools such as eyebrow pomades used also as eyeliners?

Both can be safe for use but knowing what works best with your skin type is important especially when exploring different eye makeup routines.

How to Put on Magnetic Eyelashes with Magnetic Eyeliner
How to Get Magnetic Eyeliner Off Without Makeup Remover
Best Makeup Remover for Magnetic Eyeliner
Best Eyeliner for Over 40
Best Japanese Eyeliner
Best Gold Eyeliner
Best Eyeliner for Eyelash Extensions
Kat Von D Eyeliner vs Stila
Best Eyeliners 101: Tested Top Eyeliner Reviews Guide
Can You Use Brow Pencil as Eyeliner?
No comments to show.
Mila, the veteran beauty cosmetics professional and author of this article, while cutting and styling the hair of her client

Hi! I’m Mila M. I share my 44 year-experience as a Cosmetologist & Beauty Professional in this blog. This content is for educational purposes only and does not constitute professional advice. Consult your trusted Beauty Professional for your personal beauty needs.

Get your FREE copy.

Sign Up & Subscribe

* indicates required

Intuit Mailchimp